Showing posts with label Good Bad Ugly Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Good Bad Ugly Review. Show all posts

Monday, 17 February 2014

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Review: Unique Toys' Maniaking (Galvatron)

Galvatron knows the pain of trying to transform Fansproject's Diesel
The Good
We finally have a Galvatron! After years of third party releases, Unique Toys have finally stepped up to bat and give us the toy we've wanted since Hasbro gave us the rather ugly Galvatron in the Universe line.

Don't judge a book by it's cover was never more accurate!
There have been more than a few renditions of Galvatron but it seems that Unique Toys have taken their inspiration from the Heart of Darkness covers as drawn by Ulises Farinas which is a damn decent choice.

Behold, Galvatron!
Out of the box, Maniaking is pretty impressive! The metallic purple is a nice touch and really makes the figure vibrant!  A lot of people didn't like the white legs when the first pictures emerged but in person they aren't as bad and perhaps bring a little contrast to this figure. It's very hard to imagine a figure looking like a better Galvatron than this.
A distinct lack of kibble
There's very little kibble to Maniaking which is a nice change from the usual alt-mode-hanging-off-the-back that is often found with Transformers. The back is a very simple and sparse sight which is most welcome.
First Prime, then Ultra Magnus blah blah blah
Maniaking has a fair bit of articulation and the joints are nice and stable. The shoulder joints however do feel very stiff and like they want to snap unless you move them with two hands to not put too much stress on the joint. Considering how delicate the joints are on current Hasbro products are, it's not a big deal. 


Yep, Morg still can't take decent pictures.

Maniaking is in scale with Classics and stands at Voyager size which makes him a good bit taller than Universe Cyclonus and Generations Scourge and puts him at a good height for a character of his importance.  While this is going to sound odd, the small grey pieces on his shins are a great piece of engineering which hold together the legs and then are jointed to hold together the cannon mode. It's only a very small thing but it shows how much effort went into the design process.

Will anyone else attempt to flll his shoes?

The alt mode of giant tracked space cannon thing looks fairly decent and for the first time, I've actually liked this mode with Galavtron. It's nice and stable and looks for the most part exactly how you expect it to. 

The bad

It's a nitpick on my part, but the hands don't turn. As you can see from the next two pictures, when the elbow joint is in the "proper" straight arm position, the hand's knuckles face backwards. For the hand to sit as it would with most figures, the arm has to be turned so the elbow faces out. Not a deal breaker but a definite annoyance. 




Another minor nitpick is that forearm and the big gap in it. It feels like it wouldn't have taken a lot for the parts to snugly together like the legs do amazingly when transformed into cannon mode. The forearms also feel a little brittle. They aren't, they just feel that way but it was scary to first touch them.


The transformation sequence gets a mention here because it's a masterpiece level transformation with an instruction booklet that doesn't give masterpiece level details. At the point of the picture above I was starting to wonder if I'd be able to transform it at all.


The instructions were still baffling at this point but at least the front part was now beautifully put together. 

The Ugly
The back of the cannon mode definitely qualifies as ugly. In fairness, I may not have transformed it properly but the instructions were so vague at this point that it was quickly becoming a headache.

WTF?
As above, I'm happy to admit that this may not be the way it's supposed to look but I do find it hard to imagine it looking much better unless I've missed something major. EDIT: I did miss something major - the back end of MK's arm cannon slots into the top to improve the look of the back part.

The price is a bit of a sticking point in my mind too. I'm not sure why; Maniaking is a nice figure but with the bar being raised constantly and new releases seemingly getting bigger, better and better value for money it's hard to feel that Maniaking couldn't have been a little more spectacular in terms of pricing or what it delivers.


"And these shall be your minions - Scourge, the tracker. Cyclonus, the warrior. People will argue for 30 years over who they used to be trollolololol"- Unicron (Transformers: The Movie)

Overall
Let's talk about the elephant in the room - Unique Toys. Warhawk was dire, but slowly each release has improved as UT hone their craft and Maniaking is a fantastic figure with no obvious flaws. Nothing flopped around, dropped off or failed to line up. Yes there are some niggles, but this is a company that are less than a year old and still finding their feet. Maniaking is a definite leap in the right direction for them especially as they've nailed Galavtron's likeness spectacularly!

Two points that don't really qualify as bad points are the horns which look amazing but if MK decided to fall off a shelf there's no way they would remain intact. The other is that this should have been in Masterpiece scale as it's probably the best Galavtron we'll get for a long time! If UT re-released this in a larger size and fixed the minor nuisances I outlined above then it'd be hard to imagine Takara beating it!

So, we both die in the movie. You get a shiny new body while the image of my eyes turning orange and smoke pouring out of my mouth appears in most grown men's nightmares?

Maniaking is a definite buy for Generations collectors, especially those who like their characters to look like their IDW comic counterparts. Masterpiece collectors will find that MK is way too small to stand with the Decepticon MPs but he's still in scale with the Autobot cars to a point so it's got a wide appeal. Also, a toy this good looking needs to be in a collection even if it doesn't quite fit into your collecting scale perfectly!

Even if Maniaking isn't going to make you part with your money, Unique Toys are a company to keep an eye on if Maniaking is any indication!

Monday, 21 October 2013

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Review: KFC's Mugan Scope (Perceptor)

Banksy would be proud

The Good
Initially I was very apprehensive about this release but once I had the toy in hand and first saw the beautiful job that KFC had done with the packaging, I thought I had perhaps underestimated Mugan Scope. Once out of the box, there's no other way to put it, this is an incredibly fun toy.

His is the wallet that says "Bad Mother F**ker" on it
From the thigh holsters to it's incredible level of articulation, this is one of those rare toys that actually makes me want to play with it. As one of those adult collectors who usually opens a Transformer, poses it and then sticks it on a shelf it's very rare for me to actually want to handle a toy extensively, especially as Masterpieces and Third Party aren't particularly cheap. Plus I'm clumsy. Very clumsy. 


We came here to smoke Cy-Gars and kick ass and we're all out of...oh wait, there's still one left.
Alone, Mugan Scope is pretty impressive but it really comes to life when alongside other Wrecker characters. While the sniper rifle gives him his badass look, the pistols are where it's at for posing the toy and making it look great. 


Big honking robot with big honking gun

There are a couple of neat little touches, like two heads being included so you can either have badass Wrecker Perceptor or you can have the original intellectual scientist version and just like the original G1 toy, Mugan is a triple changer with both microscope and tank modes.  


Microscope mode. Does it hold up to a closer view?

Tread carefully...

While some people have been negative about the tank mode, I personally feel it's decent and works well with the idea that Perceptor has re-engineered himself to be more combat effective, as we saw in the All Hail Megatron comics. 

The Bad
It's nitpicky of me, but Mugan Scope's wide chin gives it a very animated appearance. So while the rest of the figure looks stylised (much like Fansproject's offerings) the chin perhaps detracts from the figure if placed with Hasbro or Takara Classic figures.  

Can you see a difference?
On the subject of the head, as above, it was great that two heads are included but perhaps the lense over the right eye could have been somewhat more prominent, because as you can see above, there really isn't that much of an obvious difference between the two. In fairness, KFC have done an amazing job with the light piping so there is a striking difference between the two if there is light coming through the eyes.

Finally, while the price is about standard for a deluxe figure from a third party company, you can't help but feel that the price is about $10/£10/10 Euros too high.  

Which do you prefer?

The Ugly
The joints are nice and sturdy, but the shoulders especially need care when handled as they move in a very specific way and simply moving the arm out to the side without carefully manipulating the joint could snap the arm off. Not so much an issue, as something to be aware of.

Hold your breath around the shoulder cannon

That aside, the only real problem in this department is the shoulder cannon/microscope lense part. It definitely requires care because it is such a thin part and looks like it'd snap if it were sneezed on. The tiny balljoint is a definite issue as once it pops out, it will pop back into the socket but then constantly drop out. There's a very good reason why the pictures I took for this article don't have the cannon attached. So whatever you do, don't remove the ball joint from the socket!

Overall
KFC's first humanoid figure is a winner! A slight tweak to quality would be nice but the figure would need to remain the same price which is a big ask of such a new and small company. For such a small company to release a figure this good is very impressive and hopefully means that KFC will be a contender amongst third party companies once they've got some more experience. Mugan Scope is a definite buy for CHUG scale collectors or those who aren't interested in scale.

There's nothing more to say on this wonderful figure, so I'll leave you with some pictures that illustrate exactly how poseable it is. Give yourself a pat on the back if you get the relevance of the poses ;)